Amritsar massacre: A self inflicted crime
Amritsar witnessed many dead bodies in the name of Ramleela celebrations. Those who went to burn effigy of Ravana lie dead themselves. North India has a tradition of burning Ravan Refugee around Dasara. They burn Ravan's effigy to show the victory of good over evil. This practice has been on since many centuries. This is a celebration of Rama's triumph over Ravan. The whole event is called Ramleela. This Amritsar tragedy seems to show of we keep our evils and irresponsibilities alive, no Rama can save us and we cannot destroy any Ravan on the outside.
This incident also indicates the evil within us will burn us down by the same arrow we aimed and shot at it. A train ran over hundreds of people who had gathered near railway tracks to witness Ramleela. About 60 people died and many are lying injured in hospitals. Even the burning effigy of Ravan must have shed tears over this massive irresponsibility of people and organisers who had gathered around. Now after this ghastly incident, discussions are on about whose fault it was. Some hold the people responsible and some feel politicians are answerable for this.There are some who argue railway department was so callous regarding this event holding the train engine driver responsible.
India is the fourth country in the whole world to have biggest rail network spread across its length and breadth. At the same time, India is also home to many rail tragedies as well. In the last six years alone, more than 600 train accidents have taken place in the country. More than 60 accidents were owing to weak tracks or defects in the lines. Today the country holds lofty dreams of ‘bullet train’. This government has no responsibility towards the current rail system and strengthening it for better safety for the commuters.
The lack of basic infrastructure is affecting the railways much more than ever. This is the main contributing factor for accidents. While we talk about bullet train today we need to stop and think about the measures that make travelling by train a safe choice for common passengers. The government wants to run bullet trains to magnify its image. And it isn't saying much to the comfort of people who use the existing system everyday. Most of the train tracks and systems are from the time of Britishers. The railways isn't very enthused about fixing them. This is one of the main factors for derailment. Even the engine drivers are unable to take decisions on the face of an emergency. A very telling example of this is the train tragedy that occurred in 1981 on the bridge built across river Bagmati.
This is one of the most gruesome memory for railways. More than a thousand people died in this incident. Hundreds disappeared in the waters. The irresponsibility of the train driver is said to be the cause for this. Lack of broad platforms has also been claiming many lives annually. The same factors that contribute to road accidents apply to train tragedies too. Small incidents keep occuring on unmanned crossings across the railway network in the country. But looks like neither the people nor the railways have anything to learn from this. One thing is very clear in Amritsar tragedy. If the train had missed the track and toppled over people, the fault could have been entirely that of railways’.
But Ramleela celebrations were not organised by railways. One cannot expect the trains not to ply on tracks because of Ramleela celebrations. It is always an invitation to danger of events are held around the tracks. Even if the event is held, the organisers should ensure people do not gather on risky areas. To gather around train tracks itself is a violation of law. It is rather suicidal to stand on tracks to witness some celebration. The organisers have to take full responsibility of this loss of lives.
Another aspect to ponder about is to see whether the engine driver had any option of averting the danger. Even if he was given any signal there was hardly any chance for him to see it. Because the sound of crackers and the smoke emanating from the scene of celebration clouded his vision and ability to hear the commotion. Holding such events next to the track is the first mistake. If the train had caught fire going to all the crackers being burst in the scene the tragedy would have been a lot more bigger than what has happened now. Who would have taken responsibility for that? One cannot hold the railway department responsible for this in any manner. politicians who had participated in this event should have had some concern and responsibility to avert the tragedy.
Politicians have to advise district administration and other department people while holding mass events such as this and follow their orders regarding safety of the people. Since this was happening right next to the tracks, the departments could have held a joint meeting and arrived at the safety measures to be initiated to keep the event safe and memorable for the people who had gathered. district administration could have taken the lead on this matter since it is it’s pertinent duty. Amritsar tragedy is like a self inflicted injury more than being an accident. Everyone seems to have sponsored this massacre.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Using power to create Hindu-Muslim rift not in state or country's interest: Rahul on Sambhal clashes
New Delhi, Nov 25: A day after violence rocked Uttar Pradesh's Sambhal, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi on Monday said the BJP's use of power to create a rift between Hindus and Muslims was neither in the interest of the state nor the country.
He also urged the Supreme Court to intervene in the matter as soon as possible.
Three people were killed and scores of others, including security and administration personnel, injured on Sunday as protesters opposing a court-ordered survey of a Mughal-era mosque in Sambhal clashed with police. A fourth injured person died on Monday.
In a post in Hindi on X, Gandhi said, "The biased and hasty attitude of the state government on the recent dispute in Sambhal, Uttar Pradesh, is extremely unfortunate. I express my deepest condolences to those who have lost their loved ones in the violence and firing."
The administration, without listening to all the parties, insensitively took action that vitiated the atmosphere further and led to the deaths of people -- for which the BJP government is directly responsible, he charged.
"The BJP's use of power to create a rift and discrimination between Hindu-Muslim communities is neither in the interest of the state nor the country. I request the Supreme Court to intervene in the matter as soon as possible and do justice," Gandhi said.
The former Congress chief also appealed for peace and mutual harmony.
"We all have to join together to ensure that India moves forward on the path of unity and constitution, not communalism and hatred," Gandhi asserted.
The district administration has already imposed prohibitory orders and barred the entry of outsiders till November 30 following Sunday's clashes.
Internet services were soon suspended in Sambhal tehsil for 24 hours and the district administration declared a holiday in all schools for Monday.
Violence broke out in the district as protesters opposing the survey of the Jama Masjid clashed with security personnel. The protesters torched vehicles and pelted the police with stones while the security personnel used tear gas and batons to disperse the mob.
Tension had been brewing in Sambhal since November 19 when the Jama Masjid was first surveyed on the court's orders following a petition claiming that a Harihar temple had stood at the site.
On Sunday, trouble started early when a large group of people gathered near the mosque and started shouting slogans as the survey team began its work.
District officials said the survey could not be completed on Tuesday and was planned for Sunday to avoid interference with afternoon prayers.
Deputy Inspector General of Police (Moradabad) Muniraj told reporters on Monday that Naeem, Bilal and Nauman -- the three men who died in Sunday's violence -- had been buried. All three were aged about 25.
He later confirmed the death of a fourth person.
Divisional Commissioner (Moradabad) Aunjaneya Kumar Singh said on Sunday, "Shots were fired by miscreants... the PRO of the superintendent of police suffered a gunshot to the leg, the circle officer was hit by pellets and 15 to 20 security personnel were injured in the violence."
A constable also suffered a serious head injury while the deputy collector fractured his leg, he had said.
The Congress on Sunday alleged that the Adityanath administration was squarely responsible for killing innocents and only the BJP-RSS was guilty of "setting fire" to peace and harmony in Sambhal.
The opposition party had said the videos of direct firing on the protesters depicted the horrifying result of a "well-planned conspiracy" by Adityanath and the BJP-RSS.
संभल, उत्तर प्रदेश में हालिया विवाद पर राज्य सरकार का पक्षपात और जल्दबाज़ी भरा रवैया बेहद दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण है। हिंसा और फायरिंग में जिन्होंने अपनों को खोया है उनके प्रति मेरी गहरी संवेदनाएं हैं।
— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) November 25, 2024
प्रशासन द्वारा बिना सभी पक्षों को सुने और असंवेदनशीलता से की गई कार्रवाई ने माहौल और…
