Deaths in manholes: Will they ever end?
The ones who assured to make ‘Bharat’ a global leader at almost at the end of their term. In the next few months, well face Lok Sabha elections. By now it's pretty evident as to what people who accused others of having ruined the country for the last seventy years, have been able to achieve. The beneficiaries of their 'acche din’ are now known to everyone. The poor never stood a chance for good life. 'Digital India' still has people getting into manholes and dying a gory inhuman death. One more worker died in a manhole in the national capital Delhi few days ago. Every time a death like this occurs the government Assurance people that such incidents will never repeat in the future.
We cannot expect our prime minister to respond to such deaths. He had once written a glorious tribute to such jobs. About 123 people have died since January 2017 till date across the country. Government never thinks this is undignifying to the country's image. The ministers concerned shed a few crocodile tears before the media cameras, announce some relief, utter some assurances and forget all about that till another such death happens. But none of the assurances have materialised so far. Over 60 people have died in manholes in Karnataka from 2008. Among this, 28 deaths occurred in the capital city of Bengaluru. Government behaves irresponsibly about the deaths that should put is civil society to utter shame.
Announcing relief does not absolve the government of its moral responsibility. Facilitating the process of men getting into manhole itself is a crime. High courts and Supreme court have often chided the governments for this inhuman act still being practised. But this practice continues unabated. There are directions that specifically state manholes have to be cleaned using machines. The cleaning staff have to be given gumboots, masks and gloves. only under exceptionally inevitable circumstances should the cleaners be allowed to clean the manholes with all precautionary measures put in place.
But hardly any of these instructions are followed ever. Manholes have high quantity of Methane and carbon monoxide which are Lethal gases. A hole has to be left with its lid open for about an hour before someone gets into it. With all the precautionary measures in place, the person who gets into it has to smear his body with generous amounts of coconut oil. But none of these are ever followed. Just like our soldiers who guard our borders, our paurakarmikas go down the drain for us sometimes never to come back. A life is lost to keep the drains working, and the cities clean and beautiful. They should also be considered as Martyrs on par with the soldiers and the relief should match accordingly. The ones who force them to go down the drain should be punished severely.
The government should not play around with the lives of underprivileged people. There are only few instances where the people responsible for his death booked but mostly they go unpunished or would be let off later. The contractors and officers lead a life that are affected by these deaths. We must remember please precious lives lost our dent on India's image. They have never affected those who are polarising the country in the name of religion. The country has to bring complete ban on men being forced to go down the drain. if this cannot be done the elected representatives themselves should volunteer to get into the manholes to keep them clean. In a book written in 2008, Prime Minister Modi had said paurakarmikas must be getting a spiritual feeling to be doing their jobs. In a graded society, paurakarmikas who belong to the lowest strata are getting to experience spiritual awakening. That's not fair. All people across the social strata, including the upper caste ones should experience this spiritual feeling of getting into a manhole. Please suit yourselves on this.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Speaker rules out discussion on Guv''s conduct amid K''taka Assembly standoff
Bengaluru (PTI): In an effort to end the logjam over the Governor's address that has stalled proceedings for the past week, Karnataka Assembly Speaker U T Khader on Wednesday ruled that legislators should not discuss Thaawarchand Gehlot or his conduct in the house, saying such debates send the wrong message to the public.
The House has witnessed repeated disruptions and adjournments since the session began on January 22 over the issue of the governor's conduct.
During his address to the joint sitting of the Karnataka legislature on January 22, Gehlot read out only three sentences from the 122-paragraph speech prepared by the state government.
The speech included criticism of the Centre for replacing the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) with the Viksit Bharat–Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajivika Mission (Gramin) (VB-G RAM G), portions of which the governor declined to read.
Concluding his address in about two minutes, the governor left the house, triggering a commotion as Congress legislators attempted to gherao him and raised slogans.
While the opposition BJP accused the ruling Congress and its ministers of "insulting" the governor and demanded action, the treasury benches countered by claiming the governor had "insulted the National Anthem by leaving before it was played."
The house again witnessed heated arguments on the issue earlier in the day, leading to adjournment.
During the interruption, Khader held a meeting with ministers and opposition members to resolve the impasse.
When proceedings resumed, the speaker delivered his ruling.
Referring to the events of January 22 and the subsequent debate, Khader said the conduct and discussions had conveyed the wrong message to the public.
"Our conduct as members of this House and the opinions expressed must be in good taste and in accordance with constitutional provisions. They must uphold the dignity of the House and its members. We must introspect in this direction," he said.
He stressed the need for caution to ensure that such incidents are not repeated in the future.
"Let us end this matter here, continue the discussion on the motion of thanks to the governor, and refrain from discussing the governor or his conduct in this house," the speaker said.
Leader of the Opposition R Ashoka said the house should express regret over what he termed an "insult" to the governor.
Responding, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah said the situation would not have arisen had the governor read out the entire address.
"Asking the house to express regret is not appropriate. Why did the governor leave even before the National Anthem was played," Siddaramaiah asked.
BJP MLA S Suresh Kumar reminded Siddaramaiah that as Leader of the Opposition in 2011, he had asked then Governor Hansraj Bhardwaj to curtail his address.
Bhardwaj had subsequently placed the address on the table of the house, requesting members to treat it as read.
Siddaramaiah said the situation in January 2011 was different from the present one.
The debate grew intense, leading to another adjournment of the house.
