Present undeclared emergency worse than emergency
It has been 45 years since Indira Gandhi imposed emergency in India. From June 1975 to March 1977, for nearly two years, democracy was suspended in the country. We need to remember those tumultuous days every year to make sure that the country’s Constitution and democracy are not subjected to the same treatment again. Those two years taught us precious lessons on what happens when a leader is worshipped at the altar, and how such a leader can trample the Constitution and become a dictator. We should also remember all the tall leaders who protested against the emergency and who were responsible for reinstating democracy in the country. On Thursday, Prime Minister Narendra Modi tweeted, urging the country “to not forget those people who sacrificed their lives to protect democracy.” He also added in his statement: “The opposition against the emergency was not limited to the political class. It upset everyone. People were filled with rage and fought to bring back democracy. Every citizen felt something precious was taken away from him.” There cannot be any dispute over this. All conscientious citizens had opposed the emergency keeping aside party affiliations. Their struggles made sure that democracy that had derailed got back on track.
In the dark days of emergency, intellectuals, political thinkers, and writers were targeted and hounded. A situation was created where those who questioned the government’s decision were thrown behind bars, as any criticism of the government or its policies were considered an act of treason. Journalists who wrote against the government were also jailed. Ironically, the current situation of the country is no different. In fact, it is worse than that. But for the fact that India now has a democratically elected government in place, the country is facing an undeclared emergency and is being suffocated on all fronts. If Sanjay Gandhi’s dictatorial ways and atrocities gained notoriety during Indira Gandhi’s emergency, today we have leaders such as ‘Amit Shah’ who are trying hard to fill Sanjay Gandhi’s shoes. The acts of Adityanath in Uttar Pradesh and Kapil Mishra in Delhi remind us of emergency.
In those days of emergency, the economic life of the ordinary people was not in shambles. Instead, using the emergency, some leaders successfully implemented the Land Reforms Act which essentially involved taking away land from landlords and distributing it to the landless. When D. Devraj Urs was the Chief Minister of Karnataka, hundreds of farmers of Billava community, who were living in penury and as tenants in Mangaluru, became landowners. If Indira Gandhi had not implemented the Act ruthlessly, many backward class people would have remained tenants of the upper caste landlords. But in the 2020-undeclared emergency, several laws are being enacted to grab land from farmers and hand it over to capitalist forces. If Indira Gandhi had embarked on several revolutionary measures such as nationalizing banks, today’s government seems to be in a hurry to destroy banks and privatize them.
The decision to demonetize high value currency notes is no less significant compared to an imposition of financial emergency. Perhaps even during emergency, people were not forced to stand in queues before banks to withdraw the money that belonged to them. Even after the passage of few years, people have not yet recovered from the impact of demonetization. The financial emergency situation that people were in further deteriorated with the imposition of Covid-19 lockdown. An Act that curbs the sale of cattle by farmers was also enacted during the present undeclared emergency. Farmers, who were in distress after the demonetization, faced additional distress without being able to sell their cattle in duress. The Act was also responsible for the collapse of the animal husbandry sector. The regulations on cattle-trade helped fake cow-protectors and a few Mutts to make money in the name of cow protection. The farmers who are the real protectors of the cow were virtually on the streets.
During Indira Gandhi’s emergency, nobody asked fellow citizens to prove their citizenship. But today people are being repeatedly asked to do so. In Assam, lakhs of people who were not able to prove their citizenship were thrown into detention camps with many of them dying due to lack of food and water. Through Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), an attempt was made to divide the country into Muslims and non-Muslims. The Home Minister ignited sparks of communal hatred through the National Register of Citizens (NRC). Hundreds of students who were protesting against CAA faced jail term and many of them were killed in police firing. The plight of students was not so pathetic during Indira Gandhi’s emergency.
Thinkers, writers, and social workers who have raised their voice against the present government are being branded as ‘anti-nationals’ and are thrown into jail. Hundreds of Dalit activists including Anand Teltumbe and former police officers such as Sanjiv Bhatt are in jail for protesting against the anti-Dalit policy of the government. While a terrorist who has alleged links to the attack on Parliament gets bail, activists who are fighting for the country’s democracy are yet to get bail. With newspapers becoming government trumpets, those in the media who are exposing the scandals of the government are being harassed by the administration by misusing investigating agencies.
Even as the country was going through a series of challenges one after another, a nation-wide lockdown was imposed in the name of fighting the coronavirus. Laborers who pledged their sweat and blood for the country’s development found themselves on the street without food, water, and housing and experienced living hell unable to survive in cities or go back home. They became aliens in their own land. Indira Gandhi had declared an emergency officially. But now, emergency is prevailing in the country under the garb of democracy and the voices of those who are speaking in favor of democracy are being ruthlessly suppressed. During the emergency of Indira Gandhi, leaders with rich experience of participating in the freedom struggle came together to launch a united fight following which democracy was reinstated. But today, the country is facing a dearth of such leaders. If we do not recognize the gravity of the present emergency situation being played out as democracy and raise our voices, the country might be subjected to an official emergency soon. Before being thrown from the frying pan into the fire, the bitter memories of the 1975 emergency period should serve as a wakeup call to come together and face the horrors of the present situation.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
State govt will approach SC like Tamil Nadu if Governor rejects bills: Minister Priyank Kharge
Bengaluru: Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Minister Priyank Kharge said on Tuesday that the state government will be forced to fight against the Governor, like the Tamil Nadu government did, if the bills passed by the Karnataka government continued to be rejected by Governor Thaawar Chand Gehlot.
The Governor has returned to the government the Karnataka State Rural Development and Panchayat Raj University Bill, which focuses on replacing the Governor as the head of universities, asking for clarifications from the government.
Addressing reporters in the city on Tuesday, Minister Kharge said the government had faced similar rejection from the Governor earlier too. It had also witnessed similar situations in Tamil Nadu and Kerala, where the Governor had returned bills passed in the legislature. Admitting that the government would provide the necessary clarifications to Gehlot, Kharge said that, if the Governor was still not convinced, the state government would have to approach the Supreme Court ‘like Tamil Nadu did’.
He accused the Governor of violating the legislature’s decisions and causing a feud between the Governor and the government. He also pointed out that a bill was discussed in the legislature and passed through a voting system.
Kharge, who is spokesperson for the Karnataka government, further alleged that the BJP and the RSS were using the Governor’s office as the branch office of the party and state headquarters of the Sangh. He also accused Governor Gehlot of ‘murdering’ democracy by following the orders of the Central government and overruling the decisions of the Karnataka Legislature.
