Question of survival of democracy
Three men claiming to be from CID, went to researcher and thinker Ram Puniyani’s house, and told him they were there because his family member had applied for a passport. But Puniyani was taken by surprise because no one from his family had applied for passport. He told them that and yet the strangers didn’t leave. They began asking him very intriguing questions about his personal life, and job etc. Finally, they left him with a very disturbing veiled threat.
In another incident, government stopped giving advertisement to two prominent Kashmiri dailies. Those newspapers played important role in Kashmiri people's lives. The government didn’t give any particular reason to stop the ads to these dailies. These newspapers enjoyed most trustworthy faith of the people and media in Kashmir, so much that when they decided to protest, all other newspapers joined hands with them and displayed vacant spaces on their papers without taking ads.
Dalit thinker and professor in Lucknow University Ravikant was nominated for Ramanlal Agarwal Award given by State Government Employees Union. The award ceremony was to be held at the end of the month. But this award was withdrawn all of a sudden. The reason was that he had criticized the BJP state and central government in social media. Government tried to muzzle the voice of The Hindu paper and its editor N Ram in connection with Rafale deal.
The government argued before the court as if bringing out the names of the accused is a big crime. N Ram went on record and said there is fear in media today. If the editor of one of the oldest and most credible paper can give this statement, what would be the case of small and medium level newspapers in states and regional spaces?
The reporters and columnists who wrote against the government have been often arrested or framed in charges. A mindset has been created which says criticizing the PM is like criticizing the country. A man in UP was beaten black and blue for speaking against unemployment. The government itself is sending out messages that none should speak against the government.
When the government is weak, the miscreants would begin to walk around strutting their chest out, and attack the thinkers and journalists in broad daylight. The messed up law and order situation comes into discussion then. But what’s happening in the country is pretty different. It’s not just the miscreants, but the whole legal and police system is working to continuously launch assaults on the secular fabric of the society. When people face threat, the government has to protect them. But here, the representatives of the government, the police themselves are launching an assault. When the agencies that represent the assaulters stand to continue the tirade against thinkers and critics, it would be called an ‘emergency’. When Indira Gandhi imposed emergency, many journalists were jailed. Writers used metaphors to describe her rule. But today there is no declaration as such. But the emergency exists in the garb of democracy itself. That’s more dangerous.
Ram Puniyani has worked to take the secular heritage of this country to common people. Hundreds of writers like Puniyani are taking real message of real India to people when Sangh Parivar is trying to sell the distorted history. The government is employing police to shut the mouths of such people. A lot of human rights activists in the name of Koregaon violence, writers and thinkers have already been jailed. Government calls them Urban Naxals.
Sudha Bharadwaj is one such activist who has been arrested. On one hand our government has arrested her, and on the other, Harvard University has honored her for her work and human rights activism. Isn’t it an insult of our democracy that the government keeps her in jail whereas Harvard has honored her? Isn’t this denting the credibility of the nation in international arena? Though the government tried to arrest Anand Teltumbde, the plan was foiled last minute. World is noticing that India is going into undeclared emergency. By the time this elections are over, it would not be surprising if more people are jailed and tortured. This is why this round of elections will surely decide the survival of democracy.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Insensitive of Pune hospital to deny admission to woman, says Fadnavis; forms inquiry panel
Mumbai (PTI): Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has ordered the formation of a committee to inquire into the death of a pregnant woman after she was allegedly refused admission by Pune's leading Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital over non-payment of a deposit of Rs 10 lakh.
The controversy escalated on Friday with local political activists staging a protest outside the hospital and the hospital claiming that the woman's relatives were making misleading allegations.
A day earlier, BJP MLC Amit Gorkhe claimed in a video message that Tanisha Bhise, the wife of his personal assistant, was refused admission by the hospital. She was taken to another hospital where she died after delivering twins, he said.
A statement from the Chief Minister's Office said on Friday that he had taken serious note of the incident. "He has ordered the formation of an inquiry committee under the chairmanship of the Joint Commissioner of Charity, Pune," it said.
It said that the deputy secretary or under-secretary of the Law and Justice department would be the member secretary of the committee.
Further, instructions have been issued to the principal secretary, the Law and Justice department and the charity commissioner to ensure that the Charity Patient Scheme prepared as per the directions of the High Court is effectively implemented by all charity hospitals, the CMO said.
"All charitable hospitals should seek approval from the 'Charity Hospital Help Desk' through the online system to make reserved beds available to patients from the poor and vulnerable groups," it said.
The government has approved 186 posts of charitable health workers in charitable hospitals, and they should be filled immediately, the CMO statement said.
Talking to reporters here, Fadnavis said it was "insensitive" on the part of the hospital to deny admission to a pregnant woman.
He conceded that there was a lot of anger among the people over the incident.
"Medical ethics are needed. The Chief Minister's medical cell also intervened, but the hospital did not budge," Fadnavis said.
An internal inquiry report of the Mangeshkar Hospital claimed that the allegations of denial of admission for non-payment of Rs 10 lakh were "misleading" and made "out of frustration" by her family.
The woman's pregnancy was in the high-risk category, and her two underweight fetuses of seven months, coupled with a history of an old ailment, required Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) treatment for at least two months, it said.
The treatment required Rs 10 lakh to Rs 20 lakh and the family was advised that in case of lack of funds, they could admit the patient to the government-run Sassoon General Hospital for a complicated surgery, it added.
BJP MLC Chitra Wagh, meanwhile, came under criticism for a social media post praising the party's women's wing members who targeted and vandalised a private clinic in Pune's Kothrud area belonging to Dr Shusrut Ghaisas, who works at the hospital.
Dr Nilima Ghaisas, his mother, said her son did not practice there.
Activist Vishwambhar Choudhari criticised Wagh's remarks and claimed that the BJP-led state government recently allotted land to the hospital for Rs 1 per year rent.
The deceased woman's husband was the personal assistant of a BJP Member of the Legislative Council, yet he could not do anything, Chaudhari said.
