Ethnic aspirations define political loyalty in Bengal's Junglemahal ahead of polls
Gopiballavpur (WB) (PTI): On the surface, the political battle in the forest-covered terrain of Junglemahal in West Bengal ahead of the polls seems a power struggle like in any other part of the state, one that's marked with colourful cutouts, festoons and wall graffiti of contesting candidates, flags and banners of warring parties, and fiercely attacking political speeches sprinkled with sharp rhetoric aimed at opponents.
But scratch the surface and out comes a different, and perhaps more crucial, conflict which is not in public view, but one that has the potential to alter the fortunes of the mainstream parties jostling for political space: the simmering undercurrent of the fight for ethnic identity.
Put simply, the political loyalty of the Kudmi-Mahato community, which is fighting for its re-inclusion in the Scheduled Tribe category, seems to have taken a sharp anti-establishment turn in the state this time, while that of the tribal groups, dominated by the Santals, looks divided.
The main reason for Kudmi disillusionment with the TMC government, community leaders say, is its dilly-dallying over sending the clarifications sought by the Centre on the 2022 Cultural Research Institute (CRI) status report on the community, which has a significant population in the region, that has allegedly resulted in the holding up of its notification as a Scheduled Tribe.
"We had decided to support the TMC, if and only if the state cleared the CRI status report. Else, no vote for TMC this time. We couldn't care less about tribal reservations, and we don't want a share in the tribal quotas of the state. We only want our tribal status and true identity to be recognised," said Kalyan Mahato, the Jhargram district youth president of the Adivasi Kudmi Samaj.
An agrarian totemic group dependent mostly on forest produce, the Kudmis were removed from India's Scheduled Tribe list in 1950 and are currently engaged in an identity struggle seeking re-inclusion into the list on the grounds that they are an indigenous community, older than some of the recognised tribal groups of the region.
Over the last few years, Kudmi organisations in West Bengal and neighbouring Jharkhand have held multiple rail and road blockades in support of their demand, some of which reached violent proportions.
"The last inclusion under Article 342 of the Constitution was of the Tamaria community in Jharkhand in 2022. Like in our case, their inclusion was also held up since 2008 by TRI, the Jharkhand counterpart of CRI. It was cleared by the state's Arjun Munda-led BJP government. This time, the BJP has promised recognition of the Kudmali language and has pledged to recognise our tribe. We are hopeful," Mahato said.
"We kept our faith in the TMC for 15 years, but it failed to deliver. Let's watch the BJP for another five and see what they do," he added.
It seems sharp electoral calculations went into the BJP choosing to field Rajesh Mahato, a former Kudmi Samaj leader, as candidate from Gopiballavpur adjacent to Jhargram and Biswajit Mahato, son of community leader Ajit Mahato, from Joypur in neighbouring Purulia district, and reap political benefits from the Kudmi angst.
Rajesh, already a prominent Kudmi voice, was arrested in May 2023 in connection with the attack on TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee's convoy in Jhargram.
"He was not even present at the spot," alleged Shyam Sundar Mahato, another leader, adding that "the attack was staged".
"The stoppage of Banerjee's car was done by a spontaneous group of Kudmis who wanted to express their anguish to him. Instead, he said elsewhere that Kudmis don't vote for the TMC and that he doesn't need Kudmi support. That hurt us deeply," he said.
Shyam Sundar said the community was trying to consolidate Kudmis as a vote bank so that "established political parties start taking us seriously".
On the issue of reservation, Kalyan maintained that despite many other communities in West Bengal having received ST status, it was the Santals who derived maximum benefits from job reservation and people's representation quota.
As many as 40 ethnic groups have received ST status in West Bengal, including the Oraon, Munda, Bhumij, Lodha, and Sabar communities, as well as the Santals, the largest of them all.
"The Santals are like the big fish in a pond devouring the smaller fishes," Kalyan said.
A prominent Santal leader and chief of the Bharat Jakat Majhi Pargana Mahal, Suryakanta Murmu, said there has been no decision on who to support in the upcoming polls, but added that the large consensus is to back the TMC candidates in Jhargram and Gopiballavpur.
"We are not a political organisation. Our job is to promote Santal culture and ethnicity. Our primary demand is to form a Santal education board since, despite the state's recognition of the Santali language, the status of education of our children is quite hopeless," Murmu said.
"We don't trust the BJP, which has allowed private corporates to invade forest land in other states as well as in the Ayodhya hills of Purulia to destroy vegetation and mine minerals," he added.
Murmu, though, insisted that no matter which party he supports in the elections, it would boil down to the individual MLA to voice their concerns in the assembly.
"So far, our experience in that regard has not been good," he said.
Former chief of the Santal body, Dhanga Hansda, said a large section of the community was also facing disillusionment with the state's ruling dispensation.
"TMC MLAs from this region are members of the state Tribal Advisory Committee. I doubt whether they have spoken a word about the development of Adivasis in their meetings," Hansda said, adding that lack of teachers and adequate education infrastructure has brought Adivasi education to its knees.
"Their children go to English medium schools outside, while our children suffer," he alleged, underscoring the divide within the community.
"Whoever wins the polls from around here, the margin would be razor thin," Hansda, a Gopiballavpur resident, said.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Women's bill: This is democracy, not Hitler rule, says Dy CM Shivakumar
Bengaluru (PTI): Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar on Sunday criticised the BJP-led Centre over the timing and handling of the Women’s Reservation Amendment Bill, saying the opposition was not taken into confidence.
He also called for wider consultation in a democratic framework.
The deputy CM said the Congress has consistently supported women’s reservation, but objected to the manner in which the Bill was brought forward, alleging that it was introduced without adequate discussion with opposition parties.
“This is democracy; this is not a Hitler-style rule. They cannot bring it in the middle of elections and try to alter the entire constituencies,” Shivakumar told reporters here.
The Deputy Chief Minister maintained that the move should have been discussed across party lines.
ALSO READ: Four dead in highway pile-up in Karnataka
“They have to take everyone into confidence, but they have not done that. That is why the opposition parties have done a very good job. So, it is a victory of the INDIA alliance,” Shivakumar, who is Congress Karnataka unit president, said.
He was speaking about the setback to the BJP-led Central government, where a Constitution Amendment Bill to implement 33 per cent reservation for women in legislatures in 2029 and increase the number of Lok Sabha seats to 816 was defeated on Friday, with the ruling dispensation asserting that the struggle to give the rights to women will continue.
While 298 members voted in support of the bill in Lok Sabha, 230 MPs voted against it. Out of 528 members who voted, the bill required 352 votes for a two-third majority.
According to the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, Lok Sabha seats were to be increased to 816 from the current 543 to "operationalise" the women's reservation law before the 2029 parliamentary polls, following a delimitation exercise based on the 2011 Census.
Seats were also to be increased in state and Union territory assemblies to accommodate 33 per cent reservation for women.
Responding to BJP’s charge that the Congress is anti-women, he said, “This is not anyone’s personal property—women are the nation’s asset. We had passed this in the Rajya Sabha and Congress has already given 50 per cent reservation to women in local bodies. Even today, we support it.”
Alleging that the proposed changes could impact regional representation, Shivakumar said, “Without consulting us, they are trying to redraw constituencies, giving more weight to North India and reducing representation in South India. No one can tolerate this.”
He added that leaders including Rahul Gandhi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and several South Indian Chief Ministers have opposed the move, terming the defeat of the bills a "major victory for democracy".
The Congress Karnataka chief asserted that the Congress and the INDIA bloc stand firmly in support of women’s rights.
