Panaji (PTI): Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud on Saturday said the role of the Supreme Court as a people's court must be preserved for the future, but it does not mean that it has to fulfil the role of an Opposition in Parliament.
He said one is entitled to criticise the court for the inconsistency of legal doctrine or an error, but one cannot look at its role or its work from the perspective of outcomes.
The CJI was addressing the first Supreme Court Advocates On Record Association (SCAORA) Conference in South Goa.
"The access to justice paradigm of the Supreme Court, which has been developed over the last 75 years, is something that we should not lose track of," he said.
When societies grow and evolve into prosperity and affluence, there is a perception that you should be looking at only the big-ticket items. Ours is not a court like that. Ours is a court which is a people's court and I think the role of Supreme Court as people's court must be preserved for the future, he said.
"Now, being a people's court is not to say that we fulfil the role of the opposition in Parliament," the CJI said.
"I think, particularly in today's times, there is this great divide between everybody who thinks that the Supreme Court is a wonderful institution when you decide in their favour, and it is an institution which is denigrated when you decide against them," he said.
"I think that is a dangerous proposition because you cannot look at the role of the Supreme Court or its work from the perspective of the outcomes. The outcome of individual cases may be in your favour or maybe against you. The judges are entitled to decide with a sense of independence on a case-by-case basis," he added.
The CJI said that one is entitled to criticise the court for the inconsistency of legal doctrine or an error.
"I am sure judges have no difficulty about it, but the problem lies when the very same people see that the court is going to a particular direction are all willing to criticise it because the outcome has gone against you," he said.
The CJI said, "We as a legal profession must have a robust common sense to understand that judges are entitled and must decide on a case-by-case basis, depending on how the legal doctrine has to be applied to the facts in that particular situation."
Speaking about the initiatives taken up by the Supreme Court, the CJI said the apex court has done a lot in terms of technology, including launching e-filing of cases, digitisation of case records, conversion of constitutional bench arguments from speech-to-text or live-streaming of court proceedings.
Live-streaming of our court proceedings has been a game-changer despite the flip sides of it, he said.
"If you have seen some of the flip sides in the last few days, there are lawyers who speak to the gallery," he said, adding that now the proceedings are not just confined to the particular court room with 25 or 30 or 50 lawyers, but it goes to 20,000,000 people almost at the click of a button.
"I do believe that live-streaming is something which has taken the work of the Supreme Court of India to home and the heart of people. There was a perception on ground that the Supreme Court does cases only involving the rich and the resourceful clients," he said.
It is very easy to make that allegation against the Supreme Court because who knows who has the ability to cross-check what you are doing as citizens are outside the system, the CJI said.
"But live-streaming has changed all that because citizens now know that the smallest problems of citizens, whether there is a small bail application of someone who is seriously suffering from an element and is in custody for two years under the PMLA, under the NDPS or somebody's pension dues, somebody's service retirement dues that all these ordinary problems of simple human beings get the most serious attention of the Supreme Court," he said.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
New Delhi (PTI): When Sanjiv Suryavanshi sold his farm land to fund his 10-year-old son Vaibhav's cricketing aspirations, little did he know that within three years the boy would be scripting history.
During the second and final day of the IPL mega auction in Jeddah, Vaibhav, at 13 years and eight months, became the youngest cricketer ever to be picked by a franchise as Rajasthan Royals bought him for Rs 1.10 crore.
Sanjiv, who owned farm land in his native Motipur village which is 15kms from Samastipur town in Bihar, was lost for words.
"Woh ab sirf humra bituwa nahi pura Bihar ka bituwa hai (He is not just my son now but entire Bihar's son)," Sanjiv told PTI over phone as his son is currently in Dubai for the U-19 Asia Cup.
"My son has worked hard. At the age of 8 years, he excelled at U-16 district trials. I would take him for his cricket coaching to Samastipur and then take him back," he recalled the days of hardships.
So were his finances in place as cricket is an investment?
"Not just investment, it's big investment. Aapko kya bataye humne toh apna zameen tak bech diya. Abhi bhi halat pura sudhra nahi (I have sold my land. Financial issues are still there)."
When asked about the controversies regarding Vaibhav's actual age which many believe is 15 years, the father was quick to clarify.
"When he was 8 and half years old he first appeared for BCCI bone test. He has already played India U-19. We don't fear anyone. He can again undergo age test," he sounded defiant.
Sanjiv said that Bihar Cricket Association president Rakesh Tiwary's "blessings" have always helped Vaibhav in his journey.
"Rakesh ji ka ashirwaad raha hai bahoot (Rakesh ji's blessings are there)."
His base price in the auction was Rs. 30 lakh and Delhi Capitals made the opening bid. RR entered the fray at Rs. 35 lakh and eventually got the better of DC to get the player on board.
So how did this bidding war happened?
"Rajasthan Royals had called him for trials in Nagpur. Vikram Rathour sir (batting coach) gave a match situation where he had to score 17 in an over. Bituwa ne 3 chakka mara. Trials mein aat chakka aur char chauwaa mara (He smashed three sixes. At trials, he hit eight sixes and four fours)," the father claimed proudly.
For a 13-year-old, it can be very difficult to understand what it means to earn a crore. So how does he plan to keep his young son away from monetary discussions?
"He just wants to play cricket and nothing else. A few years back he loved Doremon, not anymore," Sanjiv said.
BCA lauds selection
=============
BCA president Tiwary was all praise for the prodigy after his 1.10 crore bid for RR.
"Vaibhav Suryavanshi's incredible achievement at such a young age fills us with immense pride," Tiwary said in a statement.
"His journey from Bihar to the IPL is a reflection of his talent, hard work, and determination. The Bihar Cricket Association has always believed in nurturing young talent, and Vaibhav's success highlights the cricketing potential in our state.
"We are confident he will continue to shine and inspire aspiring cricketers across Bihar and beyond. I congratulate Vaibhav and his family."