Bengaluru: The Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (KSHRC) has recommended a departmental enquiry and fine of Rs. 50,000 against two police personnel including a Sub-Inspector for brutally beating a man during COVID lockdown who had stepped out of his house to fetch medicine for his mother.
Hearing the complaint filed by victim Mohammed Hassan Irshad Guda, the NHRC recommended Departmental Enquiry against Bhatkal PSI Bharath Kumar and Police Constable Kuber for brutally beating Irshad during the second COVID lockdown on 8 July 2020.
The Commission has also recommended “strict action” against Bhatkal Town Circle Inspector Divakar for dereliction of duty for allegedly not initiating action when the complainant had arrived at the police station after the incident.
In his complaint, Irshad had stated he had stepped out of his house to buy medicine for his mother around 7 pm but he was brutally assaulted on the streets by PSI Bharath Kumar and his driver constable Kuber even after repeatedly telling them he had been to buy medicine.
Irshad had sustained serious injuries on his right thumb which was bleeding and had blood clotting on his waist. He also alleged that he was misbehaved with at the Bhatkal Town Police Station by the police personnel when he and his brother-in-law visited to file a complaint.
The complaint also added that Irshad was subjected to three months of bed rest after the assault.
The Commission has recommended the government pay Rs. 50,000 to the victim and has asked it to be deducted from the remuneration of Bharath Kumar and Kuber apart from instituting departmental enquiry against them. It also recommended strict action against CPI Divakar for dereliction of duty.
When Vartha Bharati contacted Bhatkal CPI Divakar to get a comment, he added he was yet to receive the copy of the order and refused to comment on the matter. The order however was issued dated 16 June 2022.
Victim Irshad welcomed the observations and recommendation of KSHRC and thanked RTI Activist Raghuvendra who took up the matter and worked tirelessly to get him justice. He also added those found guilty should be punished and strictest action should be taken against them.
The Commission has sent its order copy to Karnataka Additional Secretary to the Government and Karnataka DGP asking them to submit a report of the action taken before 15 August 2022 to the commission.


Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Mumbai (PTI): The Food and Drug Administration team probing the cause of death of four members of a family in south Mumbai's JJ Marg area have not been able to zero in on any watermelon vendor in the vicinity to check if the fruit had a role to play in the ill-fated incident, an official said on Thursday.
The Dokadia family, residents of Ghari Mohalla on Ismail Kurte Road, had hosted a get-together of relatives on the night of April 25. At around 1 am, hours after the guests had left, Abdullah Dokadia (40), his wife Nasreen (35), and daughters Ayesha (16) and Zaineb (13) ate pieces of a watermelon.
They suffered severe bouts of vomiting and diarrhoea in the early hours of April 26 and were rushed to a local hospital before being referred to the government-run J J Hospital where all four died during treatment.
"The FDA team visited the house of Dokadia and collected samples of chicken pulao and watermelon pieces. After two days, the leftover chicken pulao had developed fungus growth. The team also tried to locate watermelon vendors to check for any affected lots," he said.
But no vendors were found in the area for the past two days, preventing the FDA team from getting samples, the official added.
The FDA has requested the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL) to share the report on the food samples collected by them, he added.
A senior Mumbai police official said the force is waiting for FSL reports in the case, adding that questions on presence of sedatives etc in the fruit could be answered only then.
The statements of the kin of the deceased are being recorded to ascertain if it is a case of mass suicide, and it is being checked if the Dokadia family were in debt or distressed over some issue, the police official said.
