About Us Contact us Kannada

A group of alumni of NIMHANS on Monday wrote an open letter to the Director of NIMHANS demanding immediate withdrawal of Position Paper on Health and Wellbeing, published by the DSERT, Karnataka, for national curriculum frameworks and NEP 2020.

The experts who have urged NIMHANS to withdraw the report include Dr. Srinivas Kakkilaya, Physician, Mangaluru, Dr. Yogananda Reddy, Pediatrician, Ballari, Dr. PV Bhandary, Psychiatrist, Udupi, Dr. Shashidhar Bilagi, Psychiatrist, Bengaluru Dr. Vasudendra N, Ophthalmologist, Davanagere, Dr Rajesh Pompapathy, Radiologist Sydey, Australia, Dr. Niranjanaradhya V.P., Development Educationist and Chief  Mentor, SDMC Coordination Forum.

The letter termed the report outrageous, outdated, unscientific and frivolous.

“The Position Paper on Health and Wellbeing, published by the DSERT, Karnataka, for national curriculum frameworks and NEP 2020, is outrageous, outdated, unscientific and frivolous and must be withdrawn immediately in toto” the letter stated.

“We, as former students of NIMHANS, are aghast and deeply pained that such a ludicrous and irresponsible report bears the name of Dr.K. John Vijay Sagar, Professor and Head of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, NIMHANS as Chairperson of the Expert Group. It is also a matter of concern that this expert group on child health and nutrition does not even have a paediatrician as a member. It appears that this position paper is written by Ayurveda and Yoga ‘experts’, inserting all their baseless and dangerous ideas. We urge the Director of NIMHANS to immediately dissociate NIMHANS from this ridiculous report and we also seek the immediate resignation of Dr.K. John Vijay Sagar as Chairperson of the Expert Group. We also urge all the faculties and students of NIMHANS to oppose these attempts to misuse and malign the name of NIMHANS,” it demanded.

“The position paper claims about Panchakosha, the five layers (Sheaths) 'covering the atman'. We urge the Director as well as the Head of child psychiatry at NIMHANS to provide proof for the existence of such 'sheaths' or to immediately withdraw the paper.

“The paper also claims several benefits of yoga for mental health of children, without providing any conclusive evidence. NIMHANS must either provide conclusive evidence for these claims or withdraw this paper. Otherwise, by practising such baseless methods, children’s health will be imperilled due to denial of evidence-based methods. The report by UNICEF, titled The State of the World’s Children 2021 - Promoting, Protecting and Caring for Children's Mental Health and cited in the Paper, does not even have the word 'yoga', and has been completely ignored by the authors of the paper,” it further added.

“Further, the Paper makes many outrageous and completely baseless claims of gene-diet interactions, natural choice of plant-based food for Indians, plant-based foods being more man-friendly, Indian food culture is proven to be the best etc. Contrary to these claims, a comparison of the Indian diet with the EAT-Lancet reference diet has clearly shown that Indian diets are unhealthy and that Indians consume excess amounts of cereals and not enough proteins. Studies have also reported that 63-79% of our people, particularly in rural areas, cannot afford nutritious food. 

“The paper makes another false claim that malnutrition has reduced in India from 38.4% to 25% by 2022. The fact is that according to an analysis of the district wise data of NHFS-5, between 2016 and 2021, severe malnutrition in preschool children increased in 341 districts out of 707 and COVID19 related lockdowns and school closures would certainly worsen the situation much further,” it claimed.

“While the Position Paper blames eggs and meat for ‘lifestyle disorders’, without citing any evidence, there is now a mountain of evidence available to prove that it is the excessive consumption of sugars such as fructose (fruit sugar) and glucose (malt sugar, cereal grains) that is the most important cause for non-communicable diseases such as obesity, type 2 diabetes, hypertension, degenerative diseases and even many psychiatric problems such as ADHD, depression, anxiety etc., in children as well as adults. There is also enough evidence proving that eggs and proteins have a protective effect against obesity and other NCDs.

“The elaborate study done by the Karnataka Rural Development and Panchayati Raj University, Gadag on providing supplementary nutrition under mid-day meal scheme in Yadgir and Gadag districts has very clearly showed that children of Yadgir who received eggs in their mid-day meal had significant gains in weight and BMI. Considering such improvements, both the state and the Central governments have already decided to extend the provision of eggs in the 7 districts and also now approved similar provision of eggs in other districts as well for 46 days of the year. Therefore, the recommendation of the position paper completely goes against the decision of the Karnataka government. We hereby urge the government to extend the provision of eggs in mid-day meal for a minimum of 150 days” it said.

“The position paper makes exalted claims about equality of all children, no Pankti Bedha and Dharma in its bid to deny eggs for children. The above-mentioned study found only 4% of children in Yadgir unwilling to consume eggs and also did not show any ill effects on the minds of these 4% students who opted for bananas. Another survey conducted in 2006, when Mr. Madangopal, now the Chairperson of the NEP Task Force, was the Commissioner in the department of education, showed that out of 58 lakh students then studying in the schools of Karnataka, more than 50 lakhs had opted for eggs in the mid-day meal. With NFHS and all these surveys showing that 86-96% children and adults are eaters of eggs and meat, denying eggs for these children by citing the remaining 4-14% is cruel and undemocratic. If indeed the authors of the position paper are serious about not practising Pankti Bedha or Dharma as they claim, they should allow the majority of children to eat their eggs or other animal-based foods and allow the other children also to decide for themselves about their food choices” the letter argued.

“For these self-styled experts who are very fond of Jaiminiya Brahmana, Ayurveda, and such other ancient texts, we hereby suggest the reading of Shatapatha Brahmana (11.7.1.3 and 12.9.1.1), Jaiminiya Brahmana (1.42-44) and Manu Smriti (5:28-33), Charaka Samhita (Sharira Sthana 4:36-40 and 8:16, Sutra Sthana 27), Ashtanga Hridaya (Sutra Sthana 6) and Bhagavad Gita (17:8-10) that endorse, extoll and provide spiritual justifications for eating animal-based foods. We also suggest that they read the teachings and writings of Buddha and Basavanna, the most respected visionary philosophers of India.

“Considering all these, this Position Paper, authored by people who have absolutely no knowledge of either the modern sciences or the ancient scriptures, must be withdrawn immediately,” the letter demanded.

Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.

Comments

Noida: India TV editor-in-chief Rajat Sharma has drawn sharp criticism on social media following remarks he made on air attributing Delhi’s air pollution partly to its geographical location and the Aravalli hill range.

Speaking during a recent episode of his prime-time show Aaj Ki Baat, Sharma said Delhi’s geography plays a major role in trapping polluted air.

“Geographical location is the main reason. Delhi is a big city and its shape is like a bowl, surrounded by the Aravalli hills on three sides. As a result, polluted air gets trapped and cannot disperse easily. Therefore, the problem of pollution in Delhi cannot be solved in one year or in any particular season,” he said.

His comments came amid a severe deterioration in air quality in the national capital. On Sunday morning, December 21, Delhi woke up to a thick blanket of toxic smog, sharply reducing visibility and causing widespread discomfort. The overall Air Quality Index (AQI) stood at 390 around 7 a.m., placing it in the ‘very poor’ category, according to data from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB).

Dense fog and smog also disrupted flight operations at Delhi’s Indira Gandhi International Airport (IGIA). As many as 110 flights were cancelled, while over 370 flights were delayed due to poor visibility. Of the cancelled services, 59 were arriving flights and 51 were departures. Flight-tracking website Flightradar24 showed that departing flights faced an average delay of around 26 minutes.

Netizens troll Sharma

One user wrote on X, “Rajat Sharma is saying due to the Aravalli hills, there is air pollution in Delhi. He is defending mining and destroying the Aravalli hills like this. How can these people call themselves journalists?”

Another user accused him of political hypocrisy, comparing his earlier criticism of the Delhi government with his current remarks, and wrote, “In 2023 he blamed Arvind Kejriwal for Delhi air pollution. In 2025, he is blaming the Aravalli hills because BJP is in power. Hypocrisy = 100%, Journalism = 00%.”

Others termed the comments an example of the “godi media” narrative, alleging that geography was being blamed instead of governance, industrial emissions, vehicular pollution, construction dust, and stubble burning. “When they fail to question power or policy, they conveniently shift the blame to nature,” another post read.

“Friends, what can one even say about today’s godi media? According to them, the reason for Delhi’s pollution is that the Aravalli hills surround the city from three sides, trapping polluted air inside. Seriously? So now Sudhir Chaudhary and Rajat Sharma want us to believe that nature itself is to blame? When they fail to question power or policy, they conveniently shift the blame to geography. Apparently, it’s not years of environmental destruction or administrative failure—it’s the Aravalli hills! Does this explanation make any sense at all?,” wrote another.

What is the Aravali issue?

The controversy arises over the Union government’s revised definition of what constitutes the Aravalli hills.

The decision has drawn protests involving environmental activists across Haryana, Rajasthan, and parts of the Delhi-NCR region, who have raised concerns that the new definition could weaken protection for one of the world’s oldest mountain ranges.

Under the revised definition, an “Aravalli hill” is described as any landform in designated Aravalli districts with an elevation of 100 metres or more above local relief, while an “Aravalli range” is defined as a cluster of two or more such hills within 500 metres of each other. Activists fear this could open the door for mining, construction, and commercial activities in previously protected areas.

Environmentalists argue that the Aravalli range serves as a natural barrier against desertification, dust storms, and pollution, and plays a vital role in maintaining ecological balance in the Delhi-NCR region.

They have demanded that the entire Aravalli range be declared a fully protected area with strict conservation measures.

Meanwhile, Union Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav has stated that the new definition, accepted by the Supreme Court based on a Centre-led panel’s recommendations, would not result in any relaxation of mining norms in the Aravalli region.

All Stories

Senior citizen duped of Rs 23.5 lakh on threat of digital arrest in Thane district
Senior citizen duped of Rs 23.5 lakh on threat of digital arrest in Thane district

 A 68-year-old man was allegedly cheated of Rs 23.5 lakh by cyber fraudsters who threatened him with digital arrest in Maharashtra's Thane district, police said on Monday.
Delhi's air quality 'very poor' in Delhi
Delhi's air quality 'very poor' in Delhi

Thick grey haze shrouded Delhi on Monday morning, with the air quality remaining in the 'very poor' category with a reading of 366, according to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB).
Rupee rises 22 paise to 89.45 against US dollar in early trade
Rupee rises 22 paise to 89.45 against US dollar in early trade

The rupee appreciated 22 paise to 89.45 against the US dollar in early trade on Monday supported by foreign fund inflows and a positive trend in domestic equities.

Copyright © 2025. Vartha Bharati. All rights reserved