22 times Indian media spread misleading news on 'Pakistan Zindabad slogans'
Bengaluru: In a case of alleged media misrepresentation, Congress candidate Naseer Hussain's celebratory moment following the Rajya Sabha election results has become the center of controversy. As Hussain emerged from the Vidhan Sabha after the vote count, his supporters surrounded him, chanting slogans like "Nasir Saab Zindabad." However, certain media outlets reportedly misrepresented the cheers, framing them as "Pakistan Zindabad."
The incident gained attention as BJP supporters and some news channels amplified the false narrative, giving precedence to the allegations over the election results. Several newspapers prominently featured the BJP's claims on their front pages, sparking a debate on the responsibility of media houses in verifying information before publication.
This incident is part of a broader pattern where political opponents, especially those from the Muslim community, have been targeted with accusations of being supporters of Pakistan. Fact-checking organizations like Alt News have documented numerous instances—22 to be precise—where BJP supporters, news anchors, and media outlets have allegedly engaged in such portrayals in the past. Journalist Muhammad Zubair shared this list, highlighting a recurrent trend of attempting to brand political rivals as traitors.
- In a Muslim event organized by BJP member Shabnam Ali of Ujjain, the slogan 'Kazi Saab Zindabad' was changed to 'Pakistan Zindabad'.
- Fake news was spread that slogan of 'Pakistan Zindabad' was raised in Gram Panchayat elections in Kutch, Gujarat. Kutch SP himself later clarified that this is not Pakistan Zindabad but Radhubhai Zindabad.
- In the nomination procession of Jharkhand Mukhiya candidate Shakir Hussain, the slogan 'Shakir Hussain Zindabad' was changed to 'Pakistan Zindabad'.
- Media like Zee, Aaj Tak, ABP, News 18 carried a report in Trichy even though the slogan of 'Pakistan Zindabad' was not shouted in Uwaisi's Jharkhand rally.
- Several TV media channels, news organizations and BJP leaders have falsely claimed that 'Pakistan Zindabad' slogans were shouted when its activists protested against the NIA attack on PFI leaders in September 2022.
- Media falsely reported that AIMIM supporters shouted slogans of 'Pakistan Zindabad' in Jaipur. The slogan "Uwaisi Saab Zindabad" was broadcast wrongly.
- In February 2022, at a SP-RLD candidate rally, supporters chanted 'Akif Bhai Zindabad'. That's what the BJP leaders in Trichy had been campaigning by saying that they had shouted the slogan of 'Pakistan Zindabad'. Finally, the police chief clarified this.
- 31 Rohingyas who were 'elected' in West Bengal went viral for shouting 'Pakistan Zindabad'. In the end, Bahraich police denied this. The supporters of the newly elected Pradhan chanted slogans like 'Hajji Saab Zindabad'.
- In 2021, after the UP Panchayat election results, the media spread false news that they shouted 'Pakistan Zindabad', but in reality, the shouts of 'Haji Saab Zindabad' were distorted and spread false news.
- In November 2020, Assam BJP MLA Himanta Biswa Sharma tweeted that 'Pakistan Zindabad' slogan was shouted while welcoming All India United Democratic Front (AIUDF) chief Maulana Badruddin Ajmal at Silchar Airport. In fact AIUDF supporters chanted 'Aziz Khan Zindabad' was falsely spread as Pakistan Zindabad. This was a false news spread by BJP.
- In May 2020, a video purportedly showing supporters of Maharashtra Samajwadi Party (SP) leader Abu Azmi shouting 'Pakistan Zindabad' at Wadala station in Mumbai went viral. But when fact checked, it was found that 'Sajid Bhai Zindabad' was shouted.
- An anti-CAA rally was held in Lucknow in December 2019. BJP leaders and media spread lies that 'Pakistan Zindabad' slogan was shouted on this occasion. But later came to know that it shouted "Kashif Saab Zindabad" and spread fake news.
- Edited video of a man quoting Ravi Shankar Guruji's 2016 'World Culture Festival' event on the banks of the Yamuna river, claiming to be Naseem Khan, Congress MLA from Mumbai's Chandivali constituency. In this video clip, the person Ravi Shankar Guruji says ``Pakistan Zindabad should be accompanied by Jai Hind''. Prime Minister Modi and Rajnath Singh had said that if they have the courage, they should file a case of sedition against Ravi Shankar Guruji.
- In July 2019, a video claiming that madrasa students of Madhya Pradesh's Mandsaur had shouted slogans of 'Pakistan Zindabad' went viral. Clarifying this, Mandasaur SP said, "The children shouted 'Sabir Sir Zindabad' to their teacher.
- A video went viral in 2019 claiming that Congress party workers had shouted slogans of “Pakistan Zindabad”. When fact checked, it was found that it shouted "Bhati Saab Zindabad".
- Right-wing social media handles spread falsehoods that Saharanpur students shouted pro-Pakistan slogans in February 2023. When the news was chased, it shouted "Zayd Sir Zindabad, Zayd Sir Zindabad, Monis Sir Zindabad, Monis Sir Amar Rahe" and it was distorted as Pakistan Zindabad.
- In 2022, in Hazaribagh, Jharkhand, a false news was spread that the newly elected panchayat committee members shouted pro-Pakistan slogans during the celebration. The media had reported the same by quoting the statements of state BJP leaders. As far as the incident is concerned, FIR has been registered against 62 people. When doing a fact check about this, it was found that "Chhoti Cha Zindabad" was shouted. Chhoti Ram aka was called “Chhoti Cha” and chanted in his favour.
- In May 2022, false news was spread that pro-Pakistan slogans were shouted in Jhalawar, Rajasthan during the Eid celebration. In Alt News fact check about this, “No anti-national slogans were shouted. As the situation got out of hand, the police department arrested two Muslim youths under Section 151," a police official told Altnews.
- The media and BJP leaders spread false news claiming that pro-Pakistan slogans were shouted at a Samajwadi Party rally in Uttar Pradesh in February 2022. When fact-checked, there was nowhere to shout “Pakistan Banana High”. "Mati Chor Bhagana Hai" slogan was spread in Trichy.
- Dainik Jagran, Dainik Bhaskar, Amar Ujala and Jansatta media reported in November 2017 that they shouted slogans of 'Pakistan Zindabad' at an AIMIM rally in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh. When the fact was checked, it was found that the activists shouted "Haji Shahid Zindabad". The station house officer of the local police station also confirmed the same.
- When a Muslim leader won the sarpanch election in Katni, Madhya Pradesh in July 2022, false news was spread that pro-Pakistan slogans were shouted. When doing a fact check about this, it was found that 'Wajid Bhai Zindabad' was shouted.
- In April 2022, during the Ramanavami procession, a video of Muslim youth pelting stones and chanting Pakistan Zindabad in Newasa, Ahmednagar district of Maharashtra went viral. The Ahmednagar police, who had clarified about this, had denied that Muslims had shouted pro-Pak slogans during the Ramanavami celebrations.
A Thread 🧵
— Mohammed Zubair (@zoo_bear) February 27, 2024
We at @AltNews have observed that supporters of the BJP often portray members of opposition as pro-Pakistan. We have debunked several such claims where names of leaders have been misrepresented as ‘Pakistan Zindabad’ by BJP members & News Channels & their Anchors. 👇
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Sanjay Raut demands re-election, alleges irregularities in EVMs during Maharashtra polls
Mumbai, Nov 25: Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut on Monday demanded a re-election in Maharashtra using ballot papers, claiming there were irregularities with the electronic voting machines (EVMs).
Talking to reporters, Raut alleged several complaints about EVMs malfunctioning and questioned the integrity of the recently held elections.
The BJP-led Mahayuti won 230 out of 288 seats in the assembly elections, while the opposition Maha Vikas Aghadi managed 46 seats, with Shiv Sena (UBT) winning just 20 out of 95 seats it contested.
"We have received nearly 450 complaints regarding EVMs. Despite raising objections repeatedly, no action has been taken on these issues. How can we say these elections were conducted fairly? Hence, I demand that the results be set aside and elections be held again using ballot papers," Raut said.
Citing some instances, he said a candidate in Nashik reportedly received only four votes despite having 65 votes from his family, while in Dombivli, discrepancies were found in EVM tallies, and election officials refused to acknowledge the objections.
The Sena (UBT) leader also questioned the credibility of the landslide victories of some candidates, saying, "What revolutionary work have they done to receive more than 1.5 lakh votes? Even leaders who recently switched parties have become MLAs. This raises suspicions. For the first time, a senior leader like Sharad Pawar has expressed doubts about EVMs, which cannot be ignored."
Asked about the MVA's poor performance in the elections, Raut rejected the idea of blaming a single individual.
"We fought as a united MVA. Even a leader like Sharad Pawar, who commands immense respect in Maharashtra, faced defeat. This shows that we need to analyse the reasons behind the failure. One of the reasons is EVM irregularities and the misuse of the system, unconstitutional practices, and even judicial decisions left unresolved by Justice Chandrachud," he said.
Raut stressed that though internal differences might have existed within the MVA, the failure was collective.
He also accused the Mahayuti of conducting the elections in an unfair manner.
"I cannot call the elections fair given the numerous reports of discrepancies in EVMs, mismatched numbers, and vote irregularities across the state," Raut said.
