Fact-Check: Claims about teaching Ramayana, Mahabharata in Saudi Schools false
A recent viral claim suggesting that Saudi Arabia had introduced the teaching of two ancient Indian epics, Ramayana and Mahabharata, in their school curriculum under the ‘Vision 2030’ initiative has been debunked by Alt News.
On October 5, 2023, journalist Abhijeet Majumder shared a video report of Zee Media’s WION channel on X (formerly Twitter). The report says that the Ramayana and the Mahabharata will be taught to students in schools in Saudi Arabia. Majumder wrote that the two epics would now be taught in Saudi Arabia but they are not taught in Indian schools because India is ‘secular’. (Archive)
Saudi will now teach Ramayan and Mahabharat in school. MBS is making the curriculum more inclusive.
— Abhijit Majumder (@abhijitmajumder) October 5, 2023
Unbelievable, right?
What is more shocking?
That Ramayan and Mahabharat are not taught in Bharat’s schools. Because India is ‘secular’.pic.twitter.com/zOy3t1PbZ4
He later wrote in a tweet that the video was from 2021 but his views about the Indian school curriculum would remain the same.
This is not the first time this claim has been made on social media platforms. In April 2021, several media organisations reported that the Ramayana and the Mahabharata would be taught in Saudi Arabia as part of their ‘Vision 2030’ initiative. East Coast Daily, Times Internet’s Speaking Tree, Muslim Mirror, Aaj Tak, Janta Se Rishta, ABP Education, The Kashmiriyat, Hindustan Times, Patrika, RSS mouthpiece Organiser, India Today, News18, Zee Media’s WION, Republic TV, TV9 Hindi and Yahoo News were among the outlets that covered the news.
On April 16, 2021 Nation World News and propaganda website OpIndia Hindi published an article stating that under Saudi Arabia’s ‘Vision-2030’ students are being taught the history and culture of other countries, including Ramayana and Mahabharata, as part of cultural courses.
The misinformation, which resurfaced on social media platforms in October 2023, originated from reports dating back to April 2021. Various Indian media outlets, including East Coast Daily, Speaking Tree, Muslim Mirror, and others, had reported that Saudi Arabia was incorporating these epics into their syllabus. These claims were primarily based on a tweet by Saudi resident Nouf Al Marwaai, the founder of the Arab Yoga Foundation and a recipient of India’s Padma Shri award, who shared images of a school exam paper mentioning Ramayana and Mahabharata.
However, a detailed fact-check conducted by Indian news website Alt News dispelled these claims, revealing that the information was misleading and lacked accuracy. The reports suggesting the inclusion of these epics in the Saudi curriculum were based on a misinterpretation of Marwaai’s tweet and an exam paper from a private Indian international school.
Alt News investigated the matter further, reaching out to a senior editor based in Saudi Arabia, who clarified that there had been no official statement from the government regarding the inclusion of Ramayana and Mahabharata in the school curriculum. The editor explained that the screenshots shared by Marwaai were from a private international school’s exam paper, not a government school. These questions related to the Indian sub-continent were included in a social studies and world geography subject to test students’ knowledge. The editor emphasized that the freedom of education provided to communities in these private international schools should not be confused with the curriculum at public schools.
Additionally, Saudi journalist Omar Al Ghamdi weighed in on the matter, pointing out that private international schools had been using similar curricula for years before the ‘Vision 2030’ initiative. He highlighted the need to distinguish between the curriculum in private international schools and public schools.
Nouf Al Marwaai, the source of the initial tweet, clarified in a telephone conversation with Alt News that her statement had been taken out of context. She explained that her son studied at a private school where these references to the epics were made under the Literature subhead of the South Asian Art section. However, these references were not part of the official syllabus but were included in a historical context.
Despite these clarifications, the misinformation continued to spread on social media platforms, amplified by several right-wing users who shared the false claims without verifying their accuracy.
Ramayan and Mahabharat will soon be taught in Saudi Arabia. Crown Prince MBS has directed schools to include the two Indian epics in their curriculum. pic.twitter.com/wgsulI9sqH
— Friends of RSS (@friendsofrss) April 30, 2021
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Netanyahu recommends his Cabinet approve Hezbollah cease-fire proposal
Beirut, Nov 26: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday that he would recommend his cabinet adopt a United States-brokered ceasefire agreement with Lebanon's Hezbollah, as Israeli warplanes struck across Lebanon, killing at least 23 people.
The Israeli military also issued a flurry of evacuation warnings — a sign it was aiming to inflict punishment on Hezbollah down to the final moments before any ceasefire takes hold. For the first time in the conflict, Israeli ground troops reached parts of Lebanon's Litani River, a focal point of the emerging deal.
In a televised statement, Netanyahu said he would present the ceasefire to Cabinet ministers later on Tuesday, setting the stage for an end to nearly 14 months of fighting.
Netanyahu said the vote was expected later Tuesday. It was not immediately clear when the ceasefire would go into effect, and the exact terms of the deal were not released. The deal does not affect Israel's war against Hamas in Gaza, which shows no signs of ending.
The evacuation warnings covered many areas, including parts of Beirut that previously have not been targeted. The warnings, coupled with fear that Israel was ratcheting up attacks before a ceasefire, sent residents fleeing. Traffic was gridlocked, and some cars had mattresses tied to them. Dozens of people, some wearing their pajamas, gathered in a central square, huddling under blankets or standing around fires as Israeli drones buzzed loudly overhead.
Hezbollah, meanwhile, kept up its rocket fire, triggering air raid sirens across northern Israel.
Lebanese officials have said Hezbollah also supports the deal. If approved by all sides, the deal would be a major step toward ending the Israel-Hezbollah war that has inflamed tensions across the region and raised fears of an even wider conflict between Israel and Hezbollah's patron, Iran.
The deal calls for a two-month initial halt in fighting and would require Hezbollah to end its armed presence in a broad swath of southern Lebanon, while Israeli troops would return to their side of the border. Thousands of Lebanese troops and UN peacekeepers would deploy in the south, and an international panel headed by the United States would monitor all sides' compliance.
But implementation remains a major question mark. Israel has demanded the right to act should Hezbollah violate its obligations. Lebanese officials have rejected writing that into the proposal. Israel's Defense Minister Israel Katz insisted on Tuesday that the military would strike Hezbollah if the U.N. peacekeeping force, known as UNIFIL, doesn't provide “effective enforcement” of the deal.
“If you don't act, we will act, and with great force,” Katz said, speaking with UN special envoy Jeanine Hennis-Plasschaert.
The European Union's top diplomat, Josep Borrell, said Tuesday that Israel's security concerns had been addressed in the deal also brokered by France.
“There is not an excuse for not implementing a ceasefire. Otherwise, Lebanon will fall apart,” Borrell told reporters in Italy on the sidelines of a Group of Seven meeting. He said France would participate on the ceasefire implementation committee at Lebanon's request.
Bombardment of Beirut's southern suburbs continues
Even as Israeli, US, Lebanese and international officials have expressed growing optimism over a ceasefire, Israel has continued its campaign in Lebanon, which it says aims to cripple Hezbollah's military capabilities.
An Israeli strike on Tuesday levelled a residential building in the central Beirut district of Basta — the second time in recent days warplanes have hit the crowded area near the city's downtown. At least seven people were killed and 37 wounded, according to Lebanon's Health Ministry.
Three people were killed in a separate strike in Beirut and three in a strike on a Palestinian refugee camp in southern Lebanon. Lebanese state media said another 10 people were killed in the eastern Baalbek province. Israel says it targets Hezbollah fighters and their infrastructure.
Earlier, Israeli jets struck at least six buildings in Beirut's southern suburbs. One strike slammed near the country's only airport, sending plumes of smoke into the sky. The airport has continued to function despite its location on the Mediterranean coast next to the densely populated suburbs where many of Hezbollah's operations are based.
Israeli military spokesman Avichay Adraee issued evacuation warnings for 20 buildings in the suburbs, as well as a warning for the southern town of Naqoura where UNIFIL is headquartered.
UNIFIL spokesperson Andrea Tenenti told The Associated Press that peacekeepers will not evacuate.
Other strikes hit in the southern city of Tyre, where the Israeli military said it killed a local Hezbollah commander.
The Israeli military also said its ground troops clashed with Hezbollah forces and destroyed rocket launchers in the Slouqi area on the eastern end of the Litani River, a few kilometres from the Israeli border.
Previous ceasefire hopes were dashed
Under the ceasefire deal, Hezbollah would be required to move its forces north of the Litani, which in some places is about 30 kilometers (20 miles) north of the border.
A ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah, the strongest Iranian-backed force in the region, would likely significantly calm regional tensions that have led to fears of a direct, all-out war between Israel and Iran. It's not clear how the ceasefire will affect the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. Hezbollah had long insisted that it would not agree to a ceasefire until the war in Gaza ends, but it dropped that condition.
Hezbollah began firing into northern Israel, saying it was showing support for the Palestinians, a day after Hamas carried out its Oct. 7, 2023, attack on southern Israel, triggering the Gaza war. Israel returned fire on Hezbollah, and the two sides have been exchanging barrages ever since.
Israel escalated its campaign of bombardment in mid-September and later sent troops into Lebanon, vowing to put an end to Hezbollah fire so tens of thousands of evacuated Israelis could return to their homes.
More than 3,760 people have been killed by Israeli fire in Lebanon the past 13 months, many of them civilians, according to Lebanese health officials. The bombardment has driven 1.2 million people from their homes. Israel says it has killed more than 2,000 Hezbollah members.
Hezbollah fire has forced some 50,000 Israelis to evacuate in the country's north, and its rockets have reached as far south in Israel as Tel Aviv. At least 75 people have been killed, more than half of them civilians. More than 50 Israeli soldiers have died in the ground offensive in Lebanon.
After previous hopes for a ceasefire were dashed, U.S. officials cautioned that negotiations were not yet complete and noted there could be last-minute hitches that delay or destroy an agreement.
“Nothing is done until everything is done,” White House national security spokesman John Kirby said.
While the ceasefire proposal is expected to be approved if Netanyahu brings it to a vote in his security Cabinet, one hard-line member, National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, said he would oppose it. He said on X that a deal with Lebanon would be a “big mistake” and a “missed historic opportunity to eradicate Hezbollah.”
