Centre should bring back persons deported to Bangladesh for hearing on nationality: Supreme Court
New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday verbally observed that the Union government should bring back residents of West Bengal who have been deported to Bangladesh on suspicion of being foreigners, as an interim measure, to allow them to plead their case regarding their nationality.
The top court emphasised that individuals who claim to be Indian citizens have the right to present their case, supported by documents, before the authorities. It urged the Union government to temporarily return the deported individuals so they can be heard and allow verification of the authenticity of their documents.
A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi made the suggestion during a hearing, addressing a counsel representing the Union. Senior advocates Kapil Sibal and Sanjay Hegde appeared on behalf of the petitioners.
While acknowledging the justification for deporting an “illegal entrant” from Bangladesh, CJI Kant remarked, “If somebody has something to show you, that wait I belong to India, I am born and brought up here, and I am actually an Indian national, he has a right to plead before you.”
He also noted that there was substantial material on record, such as birth certificates and land holdings of close family members, that could serve as evidence of nationality. He pointed out that earlier, there had been inadequate inquiries before deportation.
“The allegation is that the deportee was never heard and you sent them. Why don't you, at least as a temporary measure, bring them back, give them an opportunity of hearing, verify all these documents or facts and take a holistic view," Live Law quoted the Chief Justice as saying.
The bench gave the counsel representing the Union government time until December 1 to receive instructions from the Centre on the matter.
Since May, thousands of Bengali-speaking migrant workers in states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party have reportedly been rounded up and asked to prove their Indian citizenship, with some being declared foreigners and forcibly deported to Bangladesh, despite their claims of being Indian citizens.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Congress committed to social justice, says Karnataka CM; hits out at JD(S), BJP
BJP Bengaluru (PTI): Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Sunday asserted that the Congress remains firmly committed to social justice, both in principle and practice.
"The Congress is a party committed to social justice. This ideological commitment has been demonstrated not merely through words but through action," the CM said in a statement, underlining that the party has consistently translated its philosophy into governance.
He said his recent article marking Social Justice Day has sparked debate.
Defending the piece, he said: "An article I wrote for a newspaper as part of Social Justice Day celebrations has sparked multifaceted debate in the state’s political circles. If water remains stagnant, it turns into slush; if it flows, it becomes clearer."
"The social system is similar—if it does not remain rigid and instead becomes dynamic, it transforms in a people-centric manner. From this perspective, I welcome the discussion surrounding my article," he added.
Stating that his commitment to social justice is longstanding, the CM said, "Whether in power or out of it, my stand in favour of social justice has remained unwavering. I have greater clarity about the caste system among us than the politicians criticising me."
"I am prepared for a public debate on this issue," Siddaramaiah added.
Responding to criticism from Union Minister and Janata Dal (Secular) leader H D Kumaraswamy, he said, "I have taken his allegation—that I have ‘dragged caste into the picture for the sake of a chair’—lightly."
Launching a sharp attack on JD(S) patriarch and former Prime Minister H D Deve Gowda and his family, Siddaramaiah added, "Kumaraswamy and his revered father Deve Gowda are certainly not casteists; they are against their own caste. More importantly, they are family-centric. For them, caste is merely a vote bank."
He alleged that past, present, and future top JD(S) leaders would always be members of the Gowda family, questioning how many Vokkaliga leaders the party had nurtured during Deve Gowda’s long political career.
The CM maintained that it was the Congress that had identified and politically groomed Vokkaliga leaders.
"From Kengal Hanumanthaiah to S M Krishna, hundreds of Vokkaliga leaders have been nurtured. If Kengal Hanumanthaiah, Kadidal Manjappa, and S M Krishna became chief ministers, it was because of the Congress," he said, adding that several prominent Vokkaliga leaders are currently in the party.
"If one day anyone other than a member of Deve Gowda’s family becomes chief minister, it will be through the Congress," he noted.
Highlighting inclusivity, Siddaramaiah said the Congress has enabled leaders from Vokkaliga, Lingayat, and backward communities to become chief ministers in Karnataka, and expressed gratitude to party leaders Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi for giving him a second term.
He added that leaders from the Dalit community who rise to the CM's post do so on merit, not merely caste. "I can confidently say that if someone from the Dalit community becomes chief minister in the future, it will be possible only through the Congress,” he reiterated.
He questioned whether the JD(S) or the BJP in the state is capable of fostering such aspirations. "This is the difference between the Congress, the BJP and JD(S). Therefore, I urge those accusing me of practising caste politics to introspect," the CM said.
