HC issues summons to British adventurer Bear Grylls on plea alleging copyright infringement by show
New Delhi, Dec 23: The Delhi High Court issued summons to British adventurer and television presenter Bear Grylls and others on Friday on a suit filed by an Indian script writer claiming his copyright in the original literary work was infringed by the show Get Out Alive with Bear Grylls'.
The suit sought a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from infringing upon the Indian writer's copyright and also sought damages.
Justice Amit Bansal issued summons to other defendants -- NBC Universal Inc and its Vice President Tom Shelly, Warner brothers Discovery, OTT platform Hotstar, The Walt Disney and Net Geo India.
The high court asked the defendants to file their written statements and listed the suit for further hearing on February 22, 2023.
Get Out Alive with Bear Grylls' is being produced by Grylls, NBC Universal Inc and its Vice President Tom Shelly, and is broadcast on Disney+ Hotstar, which is an OTT platform owned and run by Walt Disney.
Plaintiff Arrmann Shankar Shharma said he is engaged in the work of script writing, television/ film production, reality TV production and direction, and has been working on several projects and developing various literary/ dramatic works in multiple forms for the purpose of reality television and media entertainment.
The plaintiff, who filed the suit through advocates Imran Ali and Manpreet Kaur, said in 2009, he conceived and developed, in the form of a script, a reality show for the television titled Aakhri Dum Takk-Till the Last Breath' as per which a TV reality programme of 7-8 episodes was to be produced by taking 20 people to jungle to take up challenges to overcome the natural obstacles in different extreme terrains and sail through for about a month without any help.
He said the copyright of the script, production format and concept was duly registered and granted to the plaintiff by the Registrar of Copyrights, Corporation Office, Government of India on January 10, 2011 and the work also got registered with Film Writers Association, Mumbai.
He approached the high court contending that Grylls' show, which has been running since 2013, has infringed on his original copyright work Aakhri Dum Takk'.
"However, shockingly, in the month of March 2022, the plaintiff, through one of his close friend, came to know that his copyright in the aforesaid original literary work was being infringed by the defendants herein and a show by the name of Get Out Alive with Bear Grylls' is being produced by defendant no. 1, 2 & 4 and is getting broadcasted on Disney+ Hotstar (defendant no. 5), an OTT platform owned and run by defendant no. 6," the suit said.
Shharma claimed that he watched all the eight episodes of Grylls' show and collected evidence of the same being an exact copy of his duly protected copyrighted work.
"The locations mentioned in the said work are the same as that of the said infringing show. The entry, interval, climax and the concept of the entire infringing show was based upon and filmed in the manner so narrated and formulated by the plaintiff in his original copyrighted script which was submitted to defendant no. 3 (Warner Brothers Discovery), keeping in mind the defendant no. 1 (Grylls) as host of the program," the suit claimed.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Udupi: Two men from Belthangady awarded life imprisonment for attempt to murder a woman in 2022
Udupi: Two men from Belthangady have been sentenced to life imprisonment by a court in Udupi for attempting to murder a woman in Manchikumeri in 2022.
The sentenced men, Mithun and Nagesh Poojary, are learned to have attempted to murder Sumathi, wife of Ramanath Rai, a resident of Manchikumeri, who had a Nandini Milk Parlour at Tiger Circle, Manipal.
On February 18, 2022, Sumathi was reportedly alone at home when, at around 7 pm, Mithun, learned to be her nephew, and his friend Poojary came to the house. As Sumathi opened the door, the duo barged in and tried to strangulate her with an intention of murdering her. Sumathi reportedly lost consciousness under the attack.
The men packed her body in a sack and were then putting the sack into a suitcase to carry the body out, when they noticed that Rai and neighbours had arrived. They are learned to have opened the door when Rai knocked the door and then tried to escape. They were, however, caught by the neighbours and handed over to the police.
Further, Sumathi was found by the group in an unconscious state inside the suitcase in the house. She was rushed to the Manipal Hospital and learned to have recovered after a week of medical treatment.
A case had been registered at the Manipal Police Station.
The Udupi Principal District and Sessions Court judge Kiran S Gangannavar, who heard the case, has declared both Mithun and Poojary guilty in the case. He has awarded them life imprisonment, fined them Rs 20,000 each and, under Column 325, sentenced them to rigorous imprisonment of 5 years and fined them Rs 5,000 each.
Judge Gangannavar has directed that, of the fine, Rs 45,000 be handed to the attack victim Sumathi as relief.
Jayarama Shetty represented the government as Public Prosecutor.
