Religious sentiments can't be so fragile, says HC, quashes hate speech summons against Raj Thackeray
New Delhi, Apr 27: The Delhi High Court has quashed the summons issued to Maharashtra Navnirman Sena chief Raj Thackeray by a court in Bokaro in an alleged hate speech case, observing faith and religion are more resilient and cannot be hurt or provoked by the views of an individual.
Justice Jasmeet Singh said the unity of India lies in "coexistence" of its various religions, faiths and languages, and that religion and faith, which have and will survive for centuries, are not as fragile as human beings.
By a separate order, the judge also quashed the summons issued by a Dhanbad court to Thackeray for alleged commission of offences of murder, rioting and hate speech under IPC.
The court said the summoning order by the Bokaro court, passed in 2008, cannot be sustained on account of lack of prior sanction of the Centre or the Jharkhand government but refused to quash the criminal complaint filed against Thackeray for alleged commission of offences under sections 153A (Promoting enmity between different groups etc) and 153B (Imputations, assertions prejudicial to national-integration) of IPC.
This case arose from a 2008 speech of Thackeray when he allegedly termed 'Chhath pooja', a Hindu festival celebrated especially in Bihar and eastern Uttar Pradesh, a "drama" and "show of numerical strength".
Thackeray was represented by senior advocates Arunabh Chowdhary and Anupam Lal Das in the high court.
Several cases in relation to the alleged statement were subsequently transferred by the Supreme Court to Delhi from various states.
"I am of the view that India is a country which is unique due to various religions, faiths and languages which coexist side by side. Its unity lies in this "coexistence." Religious feelings and religious sentiments cannot be so fragile as to be hurt or provoked by a speech of an individual," said the court in an order dated March 13, which was released Thursday.
"Religion and faith are not as fragile as human beings. They have survived for centuries and will survive for many more. Faith and religion are more resilient and cannot be hurt or provoked by views of / instigation by, an individual," added the order.
By separate orders, the court also quashed summons issued to Thackeray in six other pending criminal complaints over his remarks on the festival but refused to interfere with the complaints.
In the complaint made before the Dhanbad court, it was alleged that following a speech by Thackeray in October 2008 several people forcibly entered Howrah-Bombay Mail and created a ruckus during which a person died.
The court quashed the summoning orders, passed in 2008 and 2009, on the ground of violation of Code of Criminal Procedure and lack of sanction by the central or the state government.
The court noted in the order, also released on Thursday, that the police, after conducting a detailed inquiry, filed a report stating the deceased fell down from train after losing his balance, and the finding has not been challenged.
The complaint in the Bokaro matter said Thackeray's alleged comments hurt the religious sentiments of Hindus and were provocative in nature. It said the speech was against the basic structure of the Constitution and affected the unity and integrity of India.
Thackeray's counsel said the speech seemed to have been distorted.
Without admitting that the speech was made, he said, if it caused any inadvertent and unintentional hurt to the religious sentiments of any person or community, the petitioner "tenders his unconditional apology and expresses regret and sadness for the same".
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Tribal man brings dead sister's skeleton to bank to withdraw money from her account
Keonjhar (PTI): A tribal man in Odisha's Keonjhar district on Monday brought the skeleton of his dead sister to a bank to withdraw the money deposited in her name, police said.
The incident occurred at Maliposi branch of Odisha Grameen Bank located at Patana block of Keonjhar district. The man was identified as Jeetu Munda (50) of Dianali village. He was seeking to withdraw Rs 20,000 from the bank account of his elder sister, Kalra Munda (56), who died on January 26, 2026.
"I have run several times to the bank, and the people there told me to bring the account holder to withdraw money deposited in her name. Though I told them that she had died, they did not listen to me and insisted on bringing her to the bank. Therefore, out of frustration, I dug the grave and brought out her skeleton as proof of her death," an illiterate Jeetu Munda told reporters.
Patana Police Station Inspector in charge (IIC) Kiran Prasad Sahu, who reached the bank after getting information, said, "Jeetu is an illiterate tribal man. He does not know what the legal heir or nominee is. The bank officials have failed to make him understand the procedure to withdraw money from the dead person's account."
However, after the incident, the police assured Jeetu Munda that they would facilitate the withdrawal of money from the bank account of his dead sister. Later, the skeleton was again buried at the graveyard in presence of police.
Meanwhile, local Block Development Officer (BDO) Manas Dandpat said that he was not approached by anyone for the legal heir of late Kalra Munda. "Today only, I came to know about it. We will see what can be done to resolve the issue," the BDO said.
Meanwhile, bank sources said that the nominee in Kalra Munda's bank account was also dead. Therefore, Jeetu Munda was the lone claimant over the money deposited in her name.
The local administration has directed the bank officers to make arrangements and ensure that Jeetu Munda, who is the only claimant as per the rules, gets the money as soon as possible.
