Bengaluru woman's comments on Kannada-speaking delivery agents sparks insider-outsider debate
Bengaluru: A Bengaluru woman's criticism of Swiggy for not employing Kannada-speaking delivery agents has ignited a social media controversy, rekindling the insider-outsider debate in Karnataka. Her remarks have sparked widespread discussions, with many advocating for job preferences for Kannadigas.
The woman, in a post on social media platform X (formerly Twitter), shared her dissatisfaction with the food delivery platform, stating: "Bengaluru is in Karnataka or Pakistan @swiggy Your delivery guy is neither speaking nor understanding Kannada, not even English. Do you expect us to learn his state language Hindi in our land? Stop imposing things on us and make sure your delivery persons know Kannada."
Bengaluru is in Karnataka or Pakistan @Swiggy ?
— Rekha 🌸 (@detached_98) September 12, 2024
Your delivery guy is neither speaking nor understanding #kannada ,not even #English. Do you expect us to learn his state language #Hindi in our land?
Stop imposing things on us and make sure your delivery persons know #Kannada. pic.twitter.com/smzQ6Mp7SV
The post, which has garnered over 2.35 lakh views, led to a flurry of responses. Some users defended India's linguistic diversity, while others criticized the demand for language-specific requirements. One user highlighted the potential economic impact, claiming that 53 companies, including 14 multinationals, have been approached to relocate due to the ongoing language tensions.
Commenting on the post, a user wrote: “Due to the ongoing language tensions in Karnataka, reports suggest that 53 companies have been approached by Surat, Lucknow, and Indore to relocate—14 of which are multinationals. This could significantly affect Bengaluru’s startup culture and global presence. Will the city’s tech hub status remain secure?”
Bengaluru is in Karnataka or Pakistan @Swiggy ?
— Rekha 🌸 (@detached_98) September 12, 2024
Your delivery guy is neither speaking nor understanding #kannada ,not even #English. Do you expect us to learn his state language #Hindi in our land?
Stop imposing things on us and make sure your delivery persons know #Kannada. pic.twitter.com/smzQ6Mp7SV
While some supported the woman's stance, arguing that basic communication in the local language is necessary, others dismissed the need for delivery personnel to be proficient in Kannada as long as the service was timely.
As long as the delivery is done on time who cares about the linguistic skills of the delivery boy !
— EmKay (@Bingo_mk) September 13, 2024
Is Bengaluru in Karnataka or England? As far as I know, English wasn't originally a cultural language in Karnataka.
— Ashay Pahadia (@PahadiaAshay) September 13, 2024
Hindi a state language or national official language???
— Priyaa Arya (@priyaaarya) September 13, 2024
Three language treaty??? You are above the constitution?? And what has hindi got to do with pakistan???
I know the pain, at least you spoken about this. #Kannada
— Ashwinprasad (@ashwinpck) September 14, 2024
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
'One Nation, One Election' against federal structure, practically impossible: CM Siddaramaiah
Bengaluru, Sep 18: Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Wednesday said, 'one nation, one election' is against the federal structure and practically impossible to implement, as he termed the Union cabinet's decision to accept the recommendation in this connection as a "gimmick" by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to cover up his failures.
The Congress party will oppose the 'One Nation, One Election' proposal, which carries the hidden agenda of the ruling BJP, both inside and outside the Parliament, Siddaramaiah said. The public opinion across the country is also against the proposed system.
Moving ahead with its "one nation, one election" plan, the union government on Wednesday accepted a high-level panel's recommendations for holding simultaneous polls for the Lok Sabha, state assemblies and local bodies in a phased manner after a countrywide consensus-building exercise.
"The One Nation, One Election proposal approved by the Union Cabinet is not only against the federal structure but also practically impossible to implement. The fact that such an important proposal is being rushed through without any consultation with opposition parties reveals the malicious intent of the Narendra Modi government," Siddaramaiah said in a release.
ALSO READ: INDIA bloc will soon form govt. at Centre, claims CM Siddaramaiah
It seems the central government and the Prime Minister lack even basic knowledge of what should be the priorities of a government, he said.
"Unemployment is rampant across the country, inflation is destabilizing the economy, and people are suffering due to rising prices of essential commodities. Law and order has broken down nationwide, with atrocities against Dalits and women reaching alarming levels," he alleged.
"Instead of addressing these pressing issues, the Prime Minister is trying to divert public attention with the gimmick of 'One Nation, One Election' to cover up his failures," he added.
In its report submitted to the government in March, just before the general election was announced, the panel headed by former president Ram Nath Kovind had recommended implementing "one nation, one election" in two phases -- simultaneous polls for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies in the first phase and elections for local bodies like panchayats and municipal bodies within 100 days of the general election in the second phase.
It also recommended a common electoral roll, which would need coordination between the Election Commission of India (ECI) and state election commissions.
The 'One Nation, One Election' system ws entirely anti-democratic, the CM said, adding, the proposal offers no solution to the crisis that would arise if the ruling party in either the Lok Sabha or a state assembly loses a vote of confidence.
"In such cases, a midterm election is the only proper solution. Allowing a minority party that has failed to win a vote of confidence to remain in power would be a betrayal of the democratic system," he said.
The current Election Commission does not have the capacity or resources to conduct simultaneous elections for both the Lok Sabha and state assemblies across the entire country, Siddaramaiah said. The electoral system would need to be expanded to double its current capacity, which cannot be done in haste.
"For a new electoral system to be implemented, amendments must first be made to the Representation of the People Act. In addition, at least five chapters of the Constitution would need to be amended. Even for the NDA, it would be difficult to get the necessary support to pass constitutional amendments under the current system," he opined.
"Despite knowing all this, the Narendra Modi government has approved this proposal just to create confusion among the people and cover up its failures," he alleged.
