Why we shouldn’t compare Tablighi congregation and Kumbh Mela?
The coronavirus is back in the news all over the country. The common man is anxious and confused. While politicians are conducting major election rallies, people have been prevented from earning wages for their food. Nobody seems to have a problem with election rallies during the day. But if people venture out in their cars or bikes after 10 pm, they are stopped and tortured. At the same time, the government is relaxing the regulations for the Maha Kumbh Mela.
The government that has been warning about the imposition of the lockdown in the country is at the same time allowing a huge congregation of people in the name of Kumbh Mela. The media that had branded the Tablighi convention as the ‘Coronavirus convention’ is now silent about the Kumbh Mela. If Kumbh Mela were to be compared to the movie, Bahubali, the Tablighi convention can be regarded as a five-minute short film. “The Tablighi convention took place when there was no adequate information and awareness about the Coronavirus while Kumbhamela is taking place when all of us are aware about the impact of the coronavirus”, a popular Bollywood director tweeted. And his words are nothing wrong. When the Tablighi convention was organized, the organizers did not have any information about the Coronavirus. And the government had not issued any order or guidelines about the coronavirus.
We could have condemned the Tablighi convention if it was organized by flouting any guidelines or orders. In the absence of any such violations, several cases were registered against the organizers of the convention. Similarly, the media spread rumours about the workers. By spreading lies such as about the Tablighis spitting on doctors, the media tried hard to prove that the Coronavirus spread because of this.
But finally, the courts dropped all charges against the organizers and took the media to task for spreading rumours vilifying the Tablighis. As against these, the Kumbh Mela is a clearer case. Most importantly, the Tablighi convention was not a public mela. The number of people who have gathered at the Kumbhamela is much larger than those who participated in the Tablighi convention. The fact that an indirect lockdown has been imposed in several cities including Mumbai due to the Coronavirus and at the same time the government has itself gathered crores of people in Uttarakhand has confused people. It has made people view the government’s decisions with suspicion.
If the Coronavirus does not spread when crores of people gather in Kumbh Mela, how does it spread in buses or trains? Kumbh Mela is in no way indispensable for people and people have not demanded that Kumbh Mela be organized at any cost.
Despite this, if the government is keen to gather crores of people, why should people suffer due to the curfew imposed by the government? Ironically, Uttarakhand Chief Minister Rawat has said that the Tablighi convention should not be compared to the Kumbh Mela. There is a truth in his saying. The Tablighi convention does not compare to the disaster of Kumbh Mela. Rawat has issued a hollow defense about the Kumbh Mela saying ‘the Tablighi convention took place indoors while the Kumbh Mela is taking place on the banks of a river.”
If it is true that the Coronavirus spreads only in rooms and not in public places, why was lockdown imposed for three months in public places and why were people confined within four walls? Why are the police attacking those who wander on the streets late in the night? The greatest tragedy is his statement that “Goddess Ganga will save devotees from the coronavirus.” The Central government has spent thousands of crores of rupees to protect Goddess Ganga. She has become completely maligned unable to carry the weight of the sins of her devotees.
Experts have already submitted a report that the water of Ganga is not fit for consumption. The water of Ganga has become poisonous either due to the dirt thrown by devotees or the effluents discharged from factories. Even though efforts are being made to cleanse the Ganga, the government has not succeeded in its efforts. It is not about the Ganga rescuing devotees; the Ganga should be rescued from the devotees. In fact, it is possible that the Ganga might curse devotees for abusing it during the Kumbhamela. For Haj yatra that happens at the international level, the government there imposed severe restrictions. Although it is generally very well-organized with stringent regulations, it was not allowed when the virus was on the rampage. Strict regulations have been imposed for Ramzan Umra as well.
The government took these decisions as it was concerning the people. Here, in India, by imposing lockdown and night curfew for the working class, the Indian government has made the Coronavirus a joke. All chief ministers are repeatedly issuing statements that people should comply with regulations. But people have started questioning why they should not participate in daily activities when crores of people can gather in a mela. People have lost confidence regarding the orders of the government. It is only because of the inconsistencies of the government that the spread of Coronavirus is increasing by the day. The government should take complete responsibility for this. The duality in the decisions of the government about the coronavirus, lockdown, curfew, and safe distancing is why the country has reached this stage. The government that has still not learnt its lessons is continuing its dual policies and is taking the country on the path of destruction.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
AIITA welcomes Karnataka’s ban on obscene songs in school events
Bhatkal: The Karnataka unit of the All India Ideal Teachers Association (AIITA) has welcomed the Karnataka government’s decision to strictly ban school children from dancing to obscene songs during educational and cultural programmes in government, aided, and private schools across the state.
AIITA Karnataka State President M. R. Manvi congratulated the government for taking what he termed an important step to preserve the sanctity of education.
“Such decisions to safeguard the dignity of school children and uphold the values of education are the need of the hour. This rule should not be limited to government schools alone but must be strictly implemented in all private educational institutions as well,” he said.
He further urged the government to address other concerns within school programmes.
“The government should not only prohibit obscene dances in the name of school anniversaries, but also ensure that plays and dialogues that incite religious hatred are avoided. Schools should be centres of harmony, not platforms for spreading hatred,” he added.
According to a recent circular issued by the Department of School Education and Literacy, obscene dances are adversely affecting the mental health and moral values of students.
In this regard, schools have been advised to use songs that promote nationalism, positive thinking, the greatness of Kannada culture, and value-based traditions instead of inappropriate content during programmes.
The circular also emphasises that students should be dressed in decent attire.
AIITA also backed the department’s warning that disciplinary action would be taken against head teachers if such guidelines are violated. The association has further demanded that district Deputy Directors of Public Instruction strictly monitor the implementation of these rules.
