TMC MP Yusuf Pathan moves Gujarat HC against encroachment notice by VMC
Ahmedabad, Jun 20: Former India cricketer and newly-elected Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Yusuf Pathan on Thursday approached the Gujarat High Court against a notice issued by the Vadodara civic body, asking him to remove the alleged encroachment on a piece of land owned by it in the city.
In his plea, Pathan said since the matter is over 10-years-old now and the plot in question is also in his possession, the Vadodara Municipal Corporation (VMC) should have given him a chance by issuing a show-cause notice instead of a notice that asked him to "clear the encroachment" and free the VMC-owned plot.
He also argued that the Gujarat government, which rejected the VMC's proposal to sell the land to Pathan in 2014, cannot deny the sale of land because it belonged to the civic body and not the state government.
After hearing arguments presented by senior advocate Yatin Oza, who appeared for Pathan, a single judge bench comprising Justice Sangeeta Vishen asked the VMC's lawyer to put forward the civic body's side in the next hearing scheduled on Friday.
Pathan, a former all-rounder, lives in Tadalja area of Vadodara and the plot in question is adjacent to his residence. He won from the Baharampur constituency (in Murshidabad district of West Bengal) in the Lok Sabha polls the results of which were announced on June 4.
On June 6, two days after the poll results, the BJP-ruled VMC sent a notice to Pathan for allegedly encroaching on a plot of land the civic body said belongs to it.
Oza tried to link Pathan's election as a TMC MP with the notice, saying the VMC did nothing for 10 years and suddenly sent a notice just two days after the poll results.
When Oza tried to suggest that Pathan was served notice because "his party is different", Justice Vishen asked the lawyer not to deviate and stick to the main issue.
As per the case details, it is a residential plot owned by the VMC. In 2012, Pathan had demanded this plot from the VMC because his house was adjacent to that plot. He had offered to buy it as per the market rate.
Though the proposal to sell the land to Pathan was cleared by the VMC in 2014, the state government, which is the final authority in such matters, did not give its approval. However, the land remained in "possession" of Pathan since then, Oza said.
When the court said the state government has such rights, Oza said a corporation, not the state, is the final authority in such matters as per the Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporations Act (GPMC Act) if the land belongs to the civic body and not the state government.
Oza said the VMC had decided to give this plot to Yusuf Pathan and his cricketer brother Irfan Pathan for their contribution as they were in the Indian team when this proposal was cleared. He argued that the VMC should have allotted the land when the proposal was cleared by it.
"They (VMC) should not have gone to the state government for approval. The issue was now raked up after 10 years and instead of a show-cause notice, a direct notice has been served now. As per the law, the state government's approval is not needed. VMC admitted in the notice that I am in possession of this land. I urge that this notice be treated as a show-cause notice. Otherwise bulldozers will come," said Oza.
Let the Truth be known. If you read VB and like VB, please be a VB Supporter and Help us deliver the Truth to one and all.
Odisha: Three arrested for allegedly assaulting tribal women over conversion suspicion
Bhubaneshwar: A day after Christmas, on December 26, two tribal women were allegedly tied to a tree and beaten by a mob in the Remuna area of Odisha's Balasore district. The women, accused of attempting to convert a Hindu man to Christianity, were subjected to humiliation and violence, as captured in a viral video that brought the incident to light, reported The Wire.
The victims, identified as Subhasini Singh and Sukanti Singh, were reportedly targeted after visiting Chhankhanpur hamlet in Mukhura village. Subhasini, a Christian from Makhpada village in Nilgiri, allegedly came to meet Gobind Singh, a Hindu tribal man, with the intention of persuading him to convert to Christianity. Sukanti, a local resident and Hindu, was accused of facilitating the visit.
In the video, the women are seen tied to a tree, surrounded by a hostile crowd. One man's remarks accusing them of "destroying Hindu religion and culture" and chants of "Bharat Mata ki Jai" and "Jai Shri Ram" underscore the mob's fury. Subhasini's face was smeared with a cake, which locals claimed had been brought to celebrate a religious conversion.
Subas Mallick, Inspector-in-Charge of Remuna police station, confirmed the incident and said the mob had also humiliated Gobind Singh for his alleged intent to convert. Four individuals, Bapin Nayak, Pitambar Biswal, Prashant Nayak, and Badal Panda—were detained in connection with the assault. Cases have been registered under sections of the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS) addressing assault and prevention of atrocities against scheduled tribes, as well as under the Odisha Freedom of Religion Act, 1967, which prohibits forced or induced religious conversions.
However, police later released the detainees after they reportedly expressed regret and reached an "understanding" with the victims. Gobind Singh also allegedly apologized for his intent to change his faith. Despite this, two separate cases remain under investigation.
Reactions to the incident have highlighted concerns about rising vigilantism and threats to vulnerable communities. Odisha Congress spokesperson Amiya Pandab condemned the attack as a shameful reflection of the state’s law and order situation, particularly against tribal women. Former Biju Janata Dal (BJD) MLA Latika Pradhan criticized what she called "vigilante justice," emphasizing that any alleged illegal conversions should be dealt with by law rather than mob action.
The incident has also reignited discussions about communal tensions in Odisha. Balasore, represented in the Lok Sabha by former Union Minister Pratap Sarangi, borders Mayurbhanj, the home district of President Draupadi Murmu, and Keonjhar, Chief Minister Mohan Majhi’s constituency. Both leaders are from tribal communities, underscoring the gravity of such incidents targeting vulnerable groups.
This case comes against the backdrop of Odisha’s history of communal violence, including the 2008 Kandhamal riots, which led to over 30 deaths and widespread displacement of Christians. Then-Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik, now leader of the opposition, severed ties with the BJP in 2009, citing concerns over communal discord.
As authorities probe the latest incident, it raises critical questions about the balance between protecting religious freedom and preventing vigilantism.
